preview

Confucius And Religion

Better Essays

One of the first points to note is that extreme caution has to be used when relying on any specific quote or work attributed to Confucius (born 500 BC), because historical records are either poor or non-existent. Much of the life and professional history of Confucius is not recorded in any formal sense, but has been passed down as part of Chinese social traditions, though it would be extending it too far to call it a legend; there is no doubt that he did exist. For that reason, specific acts or events that he may be associated with can never be satisfactorily substantiated. Furthermore, one point that is known is that many of the famous quotes attributed to him were collected many years after his death, and may actually be aphorisms. Nonetheless, …show more content…

Clearly, he references the idea of a heaven, but according to many religious scholars, that alone is not enough to constitute a religious worldview. In particular, in order for a body of thought to be considered religious, there has to be some reflection on the nature of the soul. Specifically, there has to be some kind of consideration on what happens to the soul after death, and what one can do to commend ones soul to whatever entity decides upon such matters, through the course of one’s earthly existence. Confucius talks only of virtue as something that happens in the relationships between human beings, not something that is done with a view to meeting religious expectations. Confucian views on the nature of ‘rules’ are helpful in analysing this; Confucius argued that it was not virtuous to simply follow rules in a dogmatic manner, as a religion would require, but the truly virtuous person continually increased their stock of knowledge and experience, such that their judgement continually improved. This matter would be far too subjective for religious beliefs.
The contrarian argument of Confucianism as a religion is somewhat convoluted, and all the less convincing as a result. It has been argued that Confucianism and particularly Confucian ethics have to be separated a little from Confucius himself. The argument runs that, because of the missing items discussed …show more content…

The total writings of Confucius could not really be taken as a religious work, but rather as a code of morality independent of any kind of religious implication; the author of this code of morality may well be a religious person, and that may occasionally reflect in his writings, but that is not the same as saying that his body of work is a religious endeavour or should be turned into one through praxis. Indeed, it might almost be taken as an anti-religious work, in the sense that it focuses solely on improving the relationships that people have between them with no other interference to detract from that; with the implication being that religion is one of the prime reasons that human beings are not humane, in the Confucian sense, towards each

Get Access