Tutorials in Introductory Physics
1st Edition
ISBN: 9780130970695
Author: Peter S. Shaffer, Lillian C. McDermott
Publisher: Addison Wesley
expand_more
expand_more
format_list_bulleted
Concept explainers
Videos
Textbook Question
thumb_up100%
Chapter 5.3, Problem 2dT
The three spherical Gaussian surfaces at right each enclose a charge
Consider the following conversation:
Student 1: “Since each Gaussian surface encloses the same charge, the net flux through each must be the same.”
Student 2: “Gauss’ law doesn't apply here. The electric field at the Gaussian surface in case B is weaker than in case A, because the surface is farther from the charge. Since the flux is proportional to the electric field strength, the flux must also be smaller in case."
Student 3: "I was comparing A and C. In C the charge outside changes the field over the whole surface. The areas are the same, so the flux must be different.”
Do you agree with any of the student's? Explain.
Expert Solution & Answer
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solution
Students have asked these similar questions
Problem 2: a conducting sphere
A conducting sphere has a positive net charge Q and radius R. (Note: since the sphere is conducting all
the charge is distributed on its surface.)
a) By reflecting on the symmetry of the charge distribution of the system, determine what the E-field
lines look like outside the sphere for any r > R. Describe the E-field in words and with a simple
sketch. Make sure to also show the direction of the E-field lines.
b) Consider a point P, shown in the figure below, at a distance rp from the center of the sphere. Your
goal for this part is to properly use Gauss' law to calculate the electric field at point P. Choose an
appropriate Gaussian surface and clearly draw it on a sketch of the wire. Show your calculation for
the electric flux through the Gaussian surface, as well as for the charge enclosed. What at is the
electric field at point P? Give both the magnitude and direction (give the magnitude in terms of the
given quantities: Q, R, rp).
c) Write an…
The figure below shows a section of a very thin, very long, straight rod with a uniform charge per unit length of λ. Point O is a perpendicular distance d from the rod. A spherical gaussian surface is centered at point O and has a radius R. (Use any variable or symbol stated above along with the following as necessary: ε0.)
A)What is the electric flux through the spherical surface if R < d?
B)What is the electric flux through the spherical surface if R > d?
Draw the electric field lines of several simple charge configurations. Keep in mind that these problems are three dimensional. For each case:
Draw the electric field lines.
Draw the Gaussian surface for the flux calculation.
State whether the flux is positive, negative, or zero.
Case 1: A charge +q when the surface is a sphere centered on the charge.
Case 2: A charge -q when the surface is a sphere centered on the charge.
Case 3: A charge +2q when a surface is a sphere centered on the charge. How does this flux compare to the flux in Case #1? (Explain)
Chapter 5 Solutions
Tutorials in Introductory Physics
Ch. 5.1 - Press a piece of sticky tape, about 15-20 cm in...Ch. 5.1 - B. Make another piece of tape a described above....Ch. 5.1 - Each member of your group should press a tape onto...Ch. 5.1 - Obtain an acrylic rod and a piece of wool or fur....Ch. 5.1 - Base your answers to the following questions on...Ch. 5.1 - Two positive point charges +q and +Q (with Qq )...Ch. 5.1 - Two more +Q charges are held in place the same...Ch. 5.1 - Rank the four cases below according to the...Ch. 5.1 - Charge an acrylic rod by rubbing it with wool....Ch. 5.1 - Hold the charges rod horizontally. Use a charges...
Ch. 5.1 - Imagine that two charged rods are held together as...Ch. 5.1 - Five short segments (labeled 1-5) of acrylic rod...Ch. 5.1 - In case A at right, a point Charge +q is a...Ch. 5.1 - A small ball with zero net charge is positively...Ch. 5.1 - Hang an uncharged metal or metal-covered ball from...Ch. 5.1 - The situation in part A suggests a way to think...Ch. 5.2 - Hold a small piece of paper (e.g., an index card)...Ch. 5.2 - The area of a flat surface can be represented by a...Ch. 5.2 - Place a large piece of graph paper flat on the...Ch. 5.2 - Fold the graph paper twice so that it forms a...Ch. 5.2 - Form the graph paper into a tube as shown. Can the...Ch. 5.2 - What must be true about a surface or a portion of...Ch. 5.2 - In the tutorial Charge, you explored the region...Ch. 5.2 - Suppose that the charge, qtest , on the pith ball...Ch. 5.2 - The quantity F/qtest evaluated at any point is...Ch. 5.2 - Sketch vectors at each of the marked points to...Ch. 5.2 - The diagram at right shows a two-dimensional top...Ch. 5.2 - Compare the magnitude of the electric field at...Ch. 5.2 - Obtain a wire loop. The Loop represents the...Ch. 5.2 - For a given surface, the electric flux, E , is...Ch. 5.2 - You will now examine the relationship between the...Ch. 5.2 - When EandA were parallel, we called the quantity...Ch. 5.3 - In the following Questions, a Gaussian cylinder...Ch. 5.3 - In the following Questions, a Gaussian cylinder...Ch. 5.3 - In the following Questions, a Gaussian cylinder...Ch. 5.3 - In the following Questions, a Gaussian cylinder...Ch. 5.3 - Are your answer to part A-C of section I...Ch. 5.3 - In part D of section I, you tried to determine the...Ch. 5.3 - Find the net flux through each of the Gaussian...Ch. 5.3 - The three spherical Gaussian surfaces at right...Ch. 5.3 - A large sheet has charge density +o . A...Ch. 5.3 - The Gaussian cylinder below encloses a portion of...Ch. 5.4 - Suppose an object moves under the influence of a...Ch. 5.4 - An object travels from point A to point B while...Ch. 5.4 - An object travels from point A to point B while...Ch. 5.4 - State the work-energy theorem in your own words....Ch. 5.4 - Draw electric field vectors at point W, X, Y, and...Ch. 5.4 - A particle with charge +qo , travels along a...Ch. 5.4 - The particle travels from point X to point Z along...Ch. 5.4 - Suppose the particle travels from point W to point...Ch. 5.4 - Compare the work done as the particle travels from...Ch. 5.4 - Suppose the charge of the particle in section II...Ch. 5.4 - Shown at right are four Points near a positively...Ch. 5.5 - A small portion near the center of a large thin...Ch. 5.5 - Use the principle of superposition to determine...Ch. 5.5 - Use the principle of superposition to determine...Ch. 5.5 - Consider instead a portion near the center of a...Ch. 5.5 - A second plate with the same magnitude charge as...Ch. 5.5 - The inner surface of one plate has a uniform...Ch. 5.5 - B. Suppose the plates are discharged, then held a...Ch. 5.5 - Compare the ratio QV that you calculated for two...Ch. 5.5 - For the following cases, state whether each of the...
Additional Science Textbook Solutions
Find more solutions based on key concepts
Show a charge arrangement and a point in space where the potential produced by the charges is zero but the E fi...
College Physics
16.71 CP A turntable 1.50 m in diameter rotates at 75 rpm. Two speakers, each giving off sound of wavelength 31...
University Physics (14th Edition)
A particles position as a function of time is given by x = x0 sint, where x0 and are constants, (a) Find expre...
Essential University Physics (3rd Edition)
Express the unit vectors in terms of (that is, derive Eq. 1.64). Check your answers several ways Also work o...
Introduction to Electrodynamics
Write each number in decimal form.
44. 8.72 × 10–10
Applied Physics (11th Edition)
The 5000 billion billion freely moving electrons in a penny repel one another. Why dont they fly out of the pen...
Conceptual Integrated Science
Knowledge Booster
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, physics and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.Similar questions
- A positive charge is located above the Gaussian cylinder. Find the sign of the flux through: Surface A: Surface B: Surface C: Can you tell whether the net flux through the Gaussian surface is positive, negative, or zero? Explain.arrow_forwardThe figures show cross sections of three-dimensional closed surfaces. They have a flat top and bottom surface above and below the plane of the page. However, the electric field is everywhere parallel to the page, so there is no flux through the top or bottom surface. The electric field is uniform over each face of the surface. Figure 10 N/C 10 N/C 10 N/C ▾ Part B For (Figure 2), does the surface enclose a net positive charge, a net negative charge, or no net charge? Match the words in the left column to the appropriate blanks in the sentences on the right. Submit an outward an inward zero no net charge a net negative charge a net positive charge There is flux through each side of the surface, which indicates that there is enclosed in this surface. Previous Answers Request Answer X Incorrect; Try Again; 4 attempts remaining You filled in 2 of 2 blanks incorrectly. Reset Helparrow_forwardPart A through part D, please Charge is distibuted uniformly over each of two spherical volumes with radius R. One sphere of charge is centered at the origin and the other at x=2R (Figure 1). Let left-hand sphere have positive charge Q and let the right-hand sphere have negative charge -Q . Part A Find the magnitude of the net electric field due to these two distributions of charge at the point x=0 on the x-axis. Express your answer in terms of the variables Q , R , and appropriate constants. Part B Find the magnitude of the net electric field at the point x=R/2 on the x-axis. Express your answer in terms of the variables Q , R , and appropriate constants. Part C Find the magnitude of the net electric field at the point x=R on the x-axis. Express your answer in terms of the variables Q, R , and appropriate constants. Part D Find the magnitude of the net electric field at the point x=3Ron the x-axis. Express your answer in terms of the variables Q, R, and appropriate constants.arrow_forward
- A cylinder of constant, positive charge density p and radius R has a cylindrical hole in it. The hole, of radius R/2 is not co-axial but centered at r = R/2 as in the diagram of the cross-section below. Find the electric field (magnitude and direction) at points A and B, both at r = R/2, but at different angles. Hint: A hole is really just a volume of no net charge that can be modeled as two overlapping volumes: one of positive charge density and one of negative charge density (but same magnitude). B R/2 R/2 R/2 R/2arrow_forwardPART 5: A very long, uniform line of charge with positive linear charge density lies A very long, uniform line of charge with positive linear charge density along the x axis. An identical line of charge lies along the y axis.Determine the electric field E(x, y) for all points in the x-y plane. + X How will the electric field change if the plane is rotated 60⁰.arrow_forwardConsider a solid conductor which has spherical Question -2 shape. Positive charge q is put on this spherical conductor. Draw the figure What is the electric field E, outside , on the surface and inside the (a) sphere? (b) Suppose that we take a similar solid conductor sphere with a hollow cavity at the central part of the sphere. Draw the figure. We put the positive charge q on the sphere. What is the charge on the inner surface (cavity surface), and outher surface of the sphere? What is the electric field E outside , on the surface, inside of the sphere, and inside the cavity? (c) Suppose that we put a negative point charge at the center of the cavity of the sphere. Draw the figure. What is the charge on the inner surface (cavity surface), and outher surface of the sphere? (d) What is the electric field E outside , on the surface, inside of the sphere, inside the cavity and on the surface of the cavity ?arrow_forward
- A solid, insulating sphere of radius a has a uniform charge density throughout its volume and a total charge of Q. Concentric with this sphere is an uncharged, conducting hollow sphere whose inner and outer radii are b and c as shown in the figure below. We wish to understand completely the charges and electric fields at all locations. (Assume Q is positive. Use the following as necessary: Q, &, a, b, c and r. Do not substitute numerical values; use variables only.) Insulator Ⓡ (a) Find the charge contained within a sphere of radius r < a. 9in E = D = (b) From this value, find the magnitude of the electric field for r < a. Conductor E = (c) What charge is contained within a sphere of radius r when aarrow_forwardCalculate the electric field for all regions for a charged sphere. The sphere has a charge density ρv from R = 2 to 3. Calculate the electric field at all regions (R<2, 2<R<3 and R>3). Submit your response with the procedure in a picture or pdf file. Please include all your steps and be as clear as you can writing all your procedures. Remember to us words explaining your steps. ..arrow_forwardThe figure below shows a section of a very thin, very long, straight rod with a uniform charge per unit length of 2. Point O is a perpendicular distance d from the rod. A spherical gaussian surface is centered at point O and has a radius R. (Use any variable or symbol stated above along with the following as necessary: o.) R 1 (a) What is the electric flux through the spherical surface if R d? DE =arrow_forward2. The two metal spheres in the figure below are connected by a metal wire with a switch in the middle. Initially, the switch is open. Sphere 1, with the larger radius, is given a positive charge. Sphere 2, with the smaller radius, is neutral. Then the switch is closed. Afterward, sphere 1 has charge Q1, is at potential V1, and the electric field strength at its surface is E1. The values for sphere 2 are Q2, V2, and E2. (Assume that the spheres are sufficiently far apart so that they do not affect each other, i.e., the wire connecting them is very long.) Sphere 1 Sphere 2 + ri > r2 r2 + Switch 2013 Pearsorn Education, inc. + + ++arrow_forwardUse the following constants if necessary. Coulomb constant, k = 8.987 x 10° N - m² /C². Vacuum permitivity, eo = 8.854 x 10-12 F/m. Magnitude of the Charge of one electron, e = -1.60217662 x 10-19 C. Mass of one electron, me = 9.10938356 x 10 31 kg. Unless specified otherwise, each symbol carries their usual meaning. For example, uC means micro coulomb. Suppose you have q = 20 µC charge placed at the orign of your coordinate system.arrow_forwardA closed surface with dimensions a=b=0.40 m and c=0.60 m is located as in the figure below, The left edge of the closed surface is located at position x= a. The electric field in the region is non-uniform and is given by E=(3.0+ 14x2 ) i N/C, where x is in meters. Calculate the net electric flux leaving the closed surface? x = a Select one: A. 3.28 B. 0.45 C. 1.34 D. 1.88 E. 4.68arrow_forwardarrow_back_iosSEE MORE QUESTIONSarrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
College PhysicsPhysicsISBN:9781305952300Author:Raymond A. Serway, Chris VuillePublisher:Cengage Learning
University Physics (14th Edition)PhysicsISBN:9780133969290Author:Hugh D. Young, Roger A. FreedmanPublisher:PEARSON
Introduction To Quantum MechanicsPhysicsISBN:9781107189638Author:Griffiths, David J., Schroeter, Darrell F.Publisher:Cambridge University Press
Physics for Scientists and EngineersPhysicsISBN:9781337553278Author:Raymond A. Serway, John W. JewettPublisher:Cengage Learning
Lecture- Tutorials for Introductory AstronomyPhysicsISBN:9780321820464Author:Edward E. Prather, Tim P. Slater, Jeff P. Adams, Gina BrissendenPublisher:Addison-Wesley
College Physics: A Strategic Approach (4th Editio...PhysicsISBN:9780134609034Author:Randall D. Knight (Professor Emeritus), Brian Jones, Stuart FieldPublisher:PEARSON
College Physics
Physics
ISBN:9781305952300
Author:Raymond A. Serway, Chris Vuille
Publisher:Cengage Learning
University Physics (14th Edition)
Physics
ISBN:9780133969290
Author:Hugh D. Young, Roger A. Freedman
Publisher:PEARSON
Introduction To Quantum Mechanics
Physics
ISBN:9781107189638
Author:Griffiths, David J., Schroeter, Darrell F.
Publisher:Cambridge University Press
Physics for Scientists and Engineers
Physics
ISBN:9781337553278
Author:Raymond A. Serway, John W. Jewett
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Lecture- Tutorials for Introductory Astronomy
Physics
ISBN:9780321820464
Author:Edward E. Prather, Tim P. Slater, Jeff P. Adams, Gina Brissenden
Publisher:Addison-Wesley
College Physics: A Strategic Approach (4th Editio...
Physics
ISBN:9780134609034
Author:Randall D. Knight (Professor Emeritus), Brian Jones, Stuart Field
Publisher:PEARSON
Electric Fields: Crash Course Physics #26; Author: CrashCourse;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mdulzEfQXDE;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY