preview

Buddhism Dbq Essay

Decent Essays

Buddhism was founded in India in the sixth century B.C.E. and gradually moved to China after the fall of the Han dynasty in 220 C.E. For several centuries Buddhism influenced China greatly. During that time to 570 C.E., China experienced an era of political instability and disunity, afterwards which the imperial structure was restored. During the 1st century C.E. the spread of Buddhism from India to China was met with mixed results, in which many Chinese people accepted Buddhism and advocated its principles such as the philosophy and promise of afterlife over the Confucian ideals that were previously instituted, but the truth was that Chinese masses turned to Buddhism for its promises of eternal enlightenment during times of struggle and invasion …show more content…

Document 3, "The Disposition of Error," and Document 5, the "Zong Mi Essay," exemplify attempts to allow both beliefs to coincide peacefully. Document 3 was written by an upper-class scholar, and addressed some areas of conflict between the two, such as Buddha not being mentioned in Confucian writings because they don't contain everything, and how it doesn't make them biased for doing so, as well as the sacrifice Buddhists make for a better life later on. Document 5 has equal views on both belief systems, because it explains how both were good for their times and had everything the people needed during their respective time periods, and that both Confucius and Buddha are both perfect sages. These documents were also written during different time periods; Document 3 towards the end of a period of political disunity, and Document 5 during the beginning of the Tang. Both documents explain how Chinese people want to assimilate Buddhism into their lives without threatening Confucian ideals. Nevertheless, Document 3 was written by an upper-classman, meaning that the objections expressed about the compatibility of Confucianism and Buddhism might not have been the same perception to the lower classes. Document 5 was written during the Tang, and it partly inferred lawfulness from these Buddhist beliefs. The purpose of the document may not have been …show more content…

Han Yu's memorial (Document 4) and the Emperor's edict in Document 6 both blame Buddhism for tainting the people of China. Document 4 addresses growing feelings of nationalism in China; which resulted in a growing stand for Confucianism, since it was a belief system founded in China. Document 6, on the other hand, revealed not a strengthening of the state, but a weakening. The beginning of the decline of Tang was all blamed on the spread of Buddhism by the imperial court. It expresses bigoted views that the elimination of Buddhism will purify Chinese society. Document 4 was clearly biased because the author was both a Confucian scholar and a court official, and he may have been influenced by a personal aspiration to stay at the top of the social hierarchy, like he was in Confucianism. The emperor in Document 6 also seems to blame his troubles on Buddhism. The emperor has never worked a day in his life, so there was no possible way that he understood the reasoning for lower class workers to turn to Buddhism. He could only guess from the state of the economy, since Buddhist monks didn't work and temples weren't taxed, which critically harmed the government's income. Buddhism's influence declined considerably provided that Confucianism was gaining a stronger foothold inside of Chinese society because of their pride and

Get Access