The Cambridge History of English and American Literature in 18 Volumes (1907–21).
Volume III. Renascence and Reformation.
§ 17. The later Hymnes
These strokes seem to be aimed partly at the degraded vein of Petrarchism, manifested abundantly in the sonnets of this period, and partly at the style of Italian romance, brought into fashion by Greene and his disciples. Spenser himself yielded not a jot to the fashion of the times. It is true that his Amoretti, written in honour of the lady to whom he was married in 1594, are conceived in the most conventional Petrarchian spirit, as what we may suppose he thought most likely to please his “Elisabeth.” But the description of “perfect love,” and the praises of Rosalind in Colin Clout’s Come Home Again, breathe the same heroic Platonism as his Hymnes to Love and Beautie; while, in his Prothalamion, and, still more, in his Epithalamion, he carries the lyrical style, first attempted in The Shepheards Calender, to an unequalled height of harmony, splendour and enthusiasm. In 1595, he again came over to England, bringing with him the second part of The Faerie Queene, which was licensed for publication in January, 1595–6. While at court on this occasion, he seems to have resolved to oppose his influence, as far as he might, to the prevailing current of taste in poetry, by publishing his youthful Hymnes in honour of Love and Beautie. Lofty and Platonic as these were in their conception, he protests, in his dedication of them to “The Right Honorable and Most Vertuous Ladies, the Ladie Margaret, Countesse of Cumberland, and the Ladie Marie, Countesse of Warwicke,” that he desires, “by way of retractation, to reforme them, making, instead of those two Hymnes of earthly or naturall love and beautie, two others of heavenly and celestiall.” In the later Hymnes, he identifies the doctrine of Platonic love, in its highest form, with the dogma of Trinity in Unity:
Finding still no opening for himself at court, Spenser returned, once more, to Ireland, in 1597, where, in September, 1598, he was appointed sheriff of Cork, as a man fitted to deal with the rebels of Munster. These, however, proved too strong for him, and, at the rising under Hugh O’Neile, earl of Tyrone, his castle of Kilcolman was taken and burned in October, 1598. He himself, escaping with difficulty, was sent by the lord deputy to London with despatches about the rebellion. His calamities seem to have broken his spirit. In spite of the favour extended to him by influential courtiers like Essex, he is said to have been oppressed by poverty; and, very soon after his arrival in London, he died in King street, Westminster, on 16 January, 1599.