A consumer is observed making two choices. First, he faces prices p = (1,3) with wealth w = 8 but is limited to purchasing no more than 3 units of good 1. Given this budget set, he chooses the bundle x = (2,2). Second, he faces prices p' = (2, 1) and wealth w' = 8 with no limit on his purchases of either good. Given this budget set, he chooses the bundle x'=(4,0). (a) Identify all revealed preferences given these choices.

Microeconomic Theory
12th Edition
ISBN:9781337517942
Author:NICHOLSON
Publisher:NICHOLSON
Chapter3: Preferences And Utility
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 3.7P
icon
Related questions
Question

please  only do: if you can teach explain each partc:

what does it mean? can you show graphs: For these to be optimal choices with such preferences, the indifference curve through a must lie entirely on or above the budget line associated with (p, w), and simi- larly for r' for the budget line associated with (p', w'). 

how do you know this:Because each of these bundles lies below the other budget line, this implies that the indifference curves must cross, which is impossible.

 

can you show graphs:

note that (3,1) is a conver combination of x and x', so for conver preferences must be weakly preferred to x (the less preferred bundle between a and a'). But then the bundle (3,5/3) must be strictly preferred z, contradicting that is optimal given the initial budget set

2. A consumer is observed making two choices. First, he faces prices p = (1,3) with wealth
w = 8 but is limited to purchasing no more than 3 units of good 1. Given this budget set, he
chooses the bundle x = (2,2). Second, he faces prices p' = (2, 1) and wealth w' = 8 with no
limit on his purchases of either good. Given this budget set, he chooses the bundle x' = (4,0).
(a) Identify all revealed preferences given these choices.
Solution: Since x is affordable when x' is chosen, r' is revealed preferred to x. Since
x' exceeds the limit on good 1 when x is chosen, x is not revealed preferred to x'.
(b)
Do this consumer's choices satisfy the Weak Axiom of Revealed Preference?
Solution: Yes. WARP says that the two bundles cannot be revealed preferred to each
other; here, only r' is revealed preferred to x.
(c) Could these choices result from the consumer choosing optimally given some mono-
tone, convex, and continuous preferences? Explain your answer carefully; you do not
have to provide a formal proof.
Solution: For these to be optimal choices with such preferences, the indifference curve
through a must lie entirely on or above the budget line associated with (p, w), and simi-
larly for x' for the budget line associated with (p', w'). Because each of these bundles lies
below the other budget line, this implies that the indifference curves must cross, which
is impossible. Alternatively, note that (3,1) is a convex combination of x and x', so for
convex preferences must be weakly preferred to a (the less preferred bundle between a
and x'). But then the bundle (3,5/3) must be strictly preferred x, contradicting that a
is optimal given the initial budget set.
Transcribed Image Text:2. A consumer is observed making two choices. First, he faces prices p = (1,3) with wealth w = 8 but is limited to purchasing no more than 3 units of good 1. Given this budget set, he chooses the bundle x = (2,2). Second, he faces prices p' = (2, 1) and wealth w' = 8 with no limit on his purchases of either good. Given this budget set, he chooses the bundle x' = (4,0). (a) Identify all revealed preferences given these choices. Solution: Since x is affordable when x' is chosen, r' is revealed preferred to x. Since x' exceeds the limit on good 1 when x is chosen, x is not revealed preferred to x'. (b) Do this consumer's choices satisfy the Weak Axiom of Revealed Preference? Solution: Yes. WARP says that the two bundles cannot be revealed preferred to each other; here, only r' is revealed preferred to x. (c) Could these choices result from the consumer choosing optimally given some mono- tone, convex, and continuous preferences? Explain your answer carefully; you do not have to provide a formal proof. Solution: For these to be optimal choices with such preferences, the indifference curve through a must lie entirely on or above the budget line associated with (p, w), and simi- larly for x' for the budget line associated with (p', w'). Because each of these bundles lies below the other budget line, this implies that the indifference curves must cross, which is impossible. Alternatively, note that (3,1) is a convex combination of x and x', so for convex preferences must be weakly preferred to a (the less preferred bundle between a and x'). But then the bundle (3,5/3) must be strictly preferred x, contradicting that a is optimal given the initial budget set.
Expert Solution
steps

Step by step

Solved in 4 steps with 4 images

Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Commodity Price
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, economics and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Microeconomic Theory
Microeconomic Theory
Economics
ISBN:
9781337517942
Author:
NICHOLSON
Publisher:
Cengage
Micro Economics For Today
Micro Economics For Today
Economics
ISBN:
9781337613064
Author:
Tucker, Irvin B.
Publisher:
Cengage,
Economics:
Economics:
Economics
ISBN:
9781285859460
Author:
BOYES, William
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Exploring Economics
Exploring Economics
Economics
ISBN:
9781544336329
Author:
Robert L. Sexton
Publisher:
SAGE Publications, Inc
Microeconomics
Microeconomics
Economics
ISBN:
9781337617406
Author:
Roger A. Arnold
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Economics (MindTap Course List)
Economics (MindTap Course List)
Economics
ISBN:
9781337617383
Author:
Roger A. Arnold
Publisher:
Cengage Learning