Was George Unjustified In Shooting Lennie Research

Did George make the right decision when he killed his best friend Lennie? George and Lennie became friends when they were young. Lennie had an aunt named Clara, that would always take good care of Lennie. Due to Lennie’s special needs, George did not want to see him go through the pain and suffering of prison and mental health care. George felt obligated to take Lennie under his wing because Lennie could not survive on his own. Lennie had a very short temper that caused him and George a lot of heartache. It eventually caused George to have to kill Lennie. Although, many say that George made the wrong choice by killing him. In fact, he made the right choice when he killed Lennie because mental health care practice was very cruel and gunshot wounds was inadequate in the 1930s. George spared Lennie from a cruel hard

This may be viewed as a compassionate homicide but killing is wrong. George took responsibility for Lennie to always protect and look after him, but he failed by taking Lennie’s

We think this because Lennie still may have a mental illness but that doesn’t make it right to kill him. “ Minimum of 25 years if a firearm is used, otherwise a minimum of 10 years.” This quote proves that if the Police found George, he would be in some huge trouble. The same thing will Lennie though if George would have been responsible and he turned him in then he would have to be in jail as long. “Death penalty or life imprisonment.” This quote proves that George has done the wrong thing by killing Lennie because George can now be on death row or life imprisonment. This is why I think George is not a true friend to

One reason George was justified in killing Lennie was because he felt he was protecting Lennie. George had made a promise to Lennie’s aunt that he would take care of him. In chapter one, George tells Lennie “No, you stay with me. Your Aunt Clara wouldn't like you running off by yourself, even if she is dead.”(Steinbeck 13) George did not want Lennie suffering. He felt he was protecting Lennie. So George took it into his own hands and quickly shot Lennie. George thought he was doing what was best for the both of them.

Should George have killed his best friend Lennie? You really have to think about this question because there can be multiple answers and thoughts. If you think about it, if George did not kill Lennie, he could have suffered an awful death or spent the rest of his life in jail behind bars. Lennie has a mind of a little kid, so he would not understand if he was put behind bars. Also, if George did not kill Lennie Curley could have made him die a very painful death, but George killed him in a way he would not feel anything.

I can only imagine what it was like for George to take care of Lennie like he has. It was obviously the right thing to do, some people just do not realize how hard that would be. There are some points in the story where George blows up on Lennie, for example, in the beginning of the book when Lennie asks where they are going George says the following, “So you forgot that awready, did you? I gotta tell you again, do I?” (Steinback-4). In my opinion I think George cares for Lennie more than people thinks he does, he is just trying to make sure Lennie doesn’t cause anymore problems. This may not sound right but I gained so much respect for George when he shot Lennie. Some people may see that as selfish but personally I see it as being courageous. He didn’t have to shoot Lennie but he felt it was the right thing to do and for him to do that showed me how much he cared for

Did George do the right thing by killing Lennie? George shot Lennie to save him from a dreadful and painful death. Curley demanded that they find Lennie to kill him, Curley orders them to fetch Crook’s shotgun, and the pack sets off after Lennie. George kills him so he does not feel like Candy who felt very bad after letting a stranger kill his dog. George decides to put him out of his misery like Carlson did with the dog. Lennie couldn’t survive on his own.

Lennie was going to die, there was no way around it. “”I’m gonna get him. I’m going for my shotgun. I’ll kill the big son-of-a-bitch myself”” (Steinbeck 96). George did not want the other men to kill him. Therefore, killing Lennie was the most humane thing for him to do. He also knew it was just

The first way I am going to argue how George isn't justified in shooting Lennie is Religion . In the Bible of Christians , it says that ''You should not kill or harm anyone in any way'' . Lennie has touched someone and they felt like they was being raped , and he killed curley's wife even though it was on a accident it is still counted as a sin . George killed Lennie through kindness because curly and the other men was going to kill him . George didn't really plan on doing it but he did kill Lennie and that is counted as murder . Some people would highly say that George isn't justified in killing

Although it would seem George betrayed Lennie’s trust, George was justified in his decision to shoot Lennie because of Lennie’s actions and safety.

There are many reasons why George might have shot Lennie, but there is only one that makes sense based on previous conversations. George’s decision to shoot Lennie was not out of malice, but out of protection and kindness, because Lennie was so kind and innocent, and George didn’t want him to suffer.

George was right to kill Lennie because Lennie would make the same mistakes he kill people and animals over and over again and George thought that Lennie could get out of hand and hurt more people in the future because lennie never knew what was right and what was wrong and he

I think george should not of shot lennie. Why becuase i think they could of got away and gone some were else. I know what lennie did was wrong but i believed he could of been punished another way. I think they should of kept running to another place and get away.

Lennie’s gargantuan body fell on the ground with a thump. Did George make the right decision? Was Lennie killed out of clemency or pure hostility? George and Lennie were companions for years, heading from farm to farm, working to save money for their own land. Lennie killed the boss’s son’s wife unintentionally after shaking her so violently that her spinal cord became damaged and caused her to die. George knew that Lennie’s life was in jeopardy, therefore he took action. He was justified in his decision to kill Lennie. George cared deeply for Lennie, he knew that an asylum was no place for Lennie and he wanted him to die at peace, therefore, the killing is justified.

Killing a friend may not always be wrong. But in the novella, “Of Mice and Men” by John Steinbeck, two friends are traveling around California during the Great Depression looking for farm work. Although it is never mentioned, Lennie -the larger and stronger of the two- has a noticeable mental handicap, which affects him deeply later on in the book. George’s actions toward Lennie in the end of the book are justified because, first George was saving Lennie from the brutality of the mob, also he was ending the mental and physical abuse from the people around Lennie, as well as George’s own frustration and mental fatigue over taking care of Lennie.