preview

This Land Is Your Land Analysis

Decent Essays

Before the broadcast of Super Bowl LI, there rumors circulating online that Lady Gaga’s Halftime Show performance was going to carry a huge political statement. What the people got, however, was a very politically tame show on the surface. The message may not have been very apparent to some viewers at first, but it was very present in the undertones. Specifically, the message carries itself the most in her choice to perform the song “This Land is Your Land” by Woodie Guthrie. To most people, the song is a simple encouraging tune about the acceptance of diversity in America, but that is not really the case. The song was written by Guthrie as a sarcastic response to Kate Smith’s version of Irving Berlin’s “God Bless America.” He had gotten tired of hearing the song repeatedly on the radio, so he wrote a song called “God Blessed America for Me,” but ended up changing the title to “This Land is Your Land” before releasing it. One factor of the song that the general public seems to unaware of is the forgotten fourth and sixth verses. The fourth verse is about how America claims to be for everyone, despite the segregation at the time, using a wall as a metaphorical representation. The sixth verse, which never made it past manuscript, is about how the citizens of America fail to help the minorities, and …show more content…

It is informative and does not seem to show any bias towards or against anyone. The structuring of the article was surprisingly well done. It fully develops its ideas and does not drag on with any excess information. It is very formal with its presentation and is overall very well written. The only complaints I have are how the writer uses certain pop artists as examples without giving the reader any information on them and how little the article focuses on Lady Gaga’s performance, but instead focuses heavily on the song’s history. While I do feel like this choice made for a better article, the title does not suggest this

Get Access