preview

Theme Of Melting Pot By Anna Quindlen

Decent Essays

The short stories, “Melting Pot”(MP) by Anna Quindlen and “Dark They Were and Golden-Eyed” (DTWAGE) by Ray Bradbury, have similarities and differences based on how they display the theme of how we relate to a new place depends on our previous experiences. Both MP and DTWAGE have characters that use their previous experiences to support the theme or a decision. In “Melting Pot”, Quindlen relates back to her experience in New York “[with] a lot of old Italians…yet somehow [they’ve] seem to have reached a nice mix [of people]” (Quindlen, par. 3). Anna Quindlen is using her past experiences in New York to conclude on how the city of New York is like a “melting pot” where sometimes people come together and sometimes draw apart. Similarly, in DTWAGE, Mrs. Bittering relates back to her past experience in her old home when she says, “‘[The furniture] looked just fine in Boston… But up at the Villa? …show more content…

Mrs. Bittering relates back to how her furniture looked in her home in Boston to decide whether the furniture would look appropriate at the Villa. MP and DTWAGE share these common ideas, but they also contradict each other because MP uses the previous experience to show acceptance and connection, while DTWAGE uses the previous experience of one person to show how his idea singles him out from another group. In MP, Quindlen shows acceptance and connection when she writes, “I am… a true resident… I am one of them, and one of us” (Quindlen par. 6). Throughout the story, Anna Quindlen uses her experience from New York to lead up to now where she feels like a true resident because she is accepted for who she is. However, in DTWAGE, Mr. Bittering’s strong desire to go to Earth separates him from the rest of the group when Bittering says, "‘We’re stranded on this

Get Access