preview

Safeguards

Decent Essays

Although the arguments on both sides of the debate are powerful, the provision of safeguards that would inevitably follow the legalisation of assisted dying would reduce, if not prevent the fears of those who oppose the change in legislation. The fear of regulating requests and judging the involvement of third parties would be overcome by the provision of a safeguard which requires any request to be assessed by two independent doctors (Kutner, 1969, p545). By having two doctors independently examine the request of the patient, the consultation would ensure that those who are pursuing assisted dying have been fully informed and have considered all other alternatives, such as the provision of palliative care (Lewis et al, 2012, p66). In theory, …show more content…

It is more important to help a person suffering from mental illness to recover, before they are legally allowed to make such a terminal decision, and after a “thorough and comprehensive attempt to improve their life we have still not made living acceptable to them, we need to allow assistance to die” (Purdy, 2015). The exclusion of mental health as a condition, ties into the safeguard of type of condition. The 2007 British Attitude Survey shows that 84% of respondents agreed that a doctor should “definitely” or “probably” be legally allowed to end a patient’s life at their request” if they are suffering from unbearable pain and terminal illness (p39). However, if assisted dying were to be legalised extending this right to those suffering from painful chronic illnesses or severe disabilities should also be considered, if these individuals make the request, sufferer from terrible quality of life and show no sign of recovery. For example, it seems immoral to allow a cancer patient to request assisted dying, but not allow a paralysed individual, like Tony Nicklinson, to request the same consideration. The main objective of this chapter is to highlight the predominant arguments in favour and against assisted dying. The analysis of these arguments and the provision of an extensive list of safeguards that would be included with the legalisation of assisted dying support the overarching argument that a liberal society must uphold the right to individual autonomy. And therefore, as long as strict safeguards are in place must allow suffering individuals the choice to end their

Get Access