preview

Paul's Case Psychoanalysis

Good Essays

In Willa Cather’s short coming of age like story “Paul’s Case,” Paul, the protagonist, shows contempt for everyone in his dull life including family and teachers and he has no friends. As a way of escaping the life that he thinks is so dreary and boring he indulges himself in his obsessions which include art, theater, music, and his job where he is an usher at Carnegie Hall in Pittsburgh. His unrealistic ideas that the art world and world of ritzy first class people is like a fantasy like utopia leads him to become obsessed even more with observing others and eventually money. He sees it that being rich is is destiny. This selfishness also leads to his compulsive lying which he mostly uses to get attention from peers. Throughout Paul also becomes more self destructive in his habits and ideas. He imagines what it would be like for his dad to shoot him, he steals money from the bank his father makes him quit his job as an usher to work at to spend on a luxurious secret vacation where he also buys a gun from his thoughts of suicide. And eventually in the end, the money that he craved/desired and thought would bring him happiness lets him down and on the converge of ultimate sorrow, he takes his own life as he jumps in front of a train. But why does he act the way he does? Well, a psychoanalysis of Paul may reveal that the reason for his actions and for committing suicide might have stemmed from the fact that his psyche lies in the id realm and he is missing a superego. First, lets look at Freud’s model of the psyche. Now, Sigmund Freud is a pretty famous psychologist from the early 20th century/late 19th century. His idea for the model originally sprouted from a young lady by the name of Anna. Anna just wanted her doctor to listen to her problems and what she had to say; later this becomes known as “chimney sweeping,” which was the main basis for Freud’s idea (). Psychoanalysis, therapy in its early days, was just observing human behavior through the word of mouth of the client. As the study of psychoanalysis moved along, physicians tried to piece together the evidence and see trends in the psychic in order to comprehend it. Thus, Freud’s model was born. He proposed that the psych had three main components; the

Get Access