preview

Jennaway Sisters And Lovers

Decent Essays

Megan Jennaway’s book Sisters and Lovers: Women and Desire in Bali reads like a traditional ethnography, but is able to be analyzed as much deeper than that based on authors that came before her. Clifford Geertz was one of the first anthropologists to focus on the positionality of the ethnographer and of the people being studied. Jennaway draws upon the works of Geertz while examining the webs of significance in the Balinese gendered spaces and relationships. She also uses ideas previously discussed by Sherry Ortner in the realm of feminist anthropology. Ortner discussed ideas such as gender hegemonies and the problem with using “women” as an analytic category. Jennaway draws upon these ideas when looking at how the ideology of gender parity …show more content…

Geertz sees the cockfights as enacting and signaling what it means to be Balinese (Geertz, 451). Geertz’s enactment of identity occurs within a group of people who share the same culture. Jennaway observes the enactment of a Balinese identity in a different sphere. She looks as the enactment of what it means to be Balinese in tourist areas and fitting Balinese culture into the “cultural boxes” that the tourists desire and expect. This Balinese identity fits in with the ignorance of a changing culture; it enacts Bali as a “pristine, unspoiled paradise… still in a state of innocence” (103). This constructs a new Balinese identity, one that many are happy to portray in order to maintain the success of the tourism industry. The identity may have been a ruse at first, but people like the Lovina Lone Rangers internalize this identity and continue to enact it even outside of the tourist areas …show more content…

Hegemonies, as Ortner uses them, relate the whole social process to specific distributions of power and influence (Ortner, 145). Gender is not always the most important axis to examine power in society; sometimes the power could be distributed along a different axis such as age or economic class (146). The gender hegemony, which seems to couple with an economic hegemony, is seen in Jennaway’s distinctions between what people believe and what actually happens in the society. There is an idea of gender parity across the sexes, yet women are subordinated in practice (Jennaway, 33-4). Men have a higher status and more economic security (59). Women do the housework and care for the children while still doing other jobs that they are able to secure (49-51). Women are not only subordinate within the confines of their household, but they are muted in society. Women are represented in the sankapan only by men; it is only after menopause that women may gain some social power and a political voice of their own

Get Access