preview

If the Coat Fits Wear It

Better Essays

Solution to Case 103

IF THE COAT FITS WEAR IT – TEACHING NOTE

Questions
1. Your supervisor, Vic Gonzales, has asked you to prepare a capital budgeting report indicating whether ISGC should replace the existing machine or not. Indicate how would you proceed (without making any calculations)?

I would estimate the incremental cash flows over the economic life of the new machine, taking into consideration the after-tax salvage values of the old and new machine respectively. Changes in net working capital would be figured in as well. For the terminal year, we would assume that the net working capital is recovered and treat it as a cash inflow.

2. Explain the relevance of incremental cash flows, sunk costs, and incidental …show more content…

Furthermore, since depreciation is not really a cash outflow, it is added back to earnings before interest and taxes to calculate the operating cash flow.

6. As a shrewd financial analyst you observe that the net working capital of the firm has typically been about 20% of the annual revenues. How would you incorporate this observation into the analysis?

I would calculate the annual net working capital (NWC) based on 20% of the annual forecasted incremental revenues. Next, I would calculate the change in NWC each year. If NWC gets larger than the starting level of $44,000, it would be accounted for as a cash outflow and vice versa. At the end of the productive life of the machine, the NWC is assumed to be recovered and is treated as a cash inflow. No taxes have to be paid on this amount.

7. How should the annual interest expenses on the bank loan be handled? Explain.
The annual interest expenses should be ignored. This is done to avoid double counting the interest expense. The after-tax cost of borrowing is included in the weighted average cost of capital or discount rate. By discounting the cash flows to calculate the Net Present Value, interest costs are factored in.

8. What is the relevance of the terminal year cash flow? Which factors must be considered when estimating the terminal year cash flow?

The terminal year cash flow accounts for the recovery of NWC, the after-tax salvage value of the new machine, and the lost

Get Access