preview

Gallipoli Primary Sources

Decent Essays

Discuss the reliability of source to a historian studying the experiences of Australians at World War I during the Gallipoli campaign

Source A is highly reliable for a historian studying the experiences of Australians at Gallipoli as it is a first person account of many aspects of the experience and highly corroborates with our own knowledge of the first days at Gallipoli. Source A is a diary entry by Ellis Silas, dated 11th of May 1915, therefore it is highly reliable as it is a primary and first person account of the sixteenth day at Gallipoli. In addition, the author has most likely written the content, recalling the events still vivid in the his head which allows the chance for the author to write in immense detail. For example, “noise of the incessant crackling of rifles and screaming of shrapnel” allows the audience to visualise and understand the conditions of the day due to the author’s use of descriptive language. Furthermore, the diary entry is published on a website organised by the government, therefore it is a source that the government have examined and approved of, increasing its reliability. The majority of the diary entry is reflective of what the audience know about the first few weeks of the war such as the immense number of losses, which …show more content…

For example, “Turks, infinitely superior...in numbers and equipment; their machine guns are a much better class than ours.”

Get Access