Friar Lawrence is responsible for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet because Friar could have told everyone that they were married and he gives Juliet the potion. This conflict could have easily been resolved if Friar Lawrence would have been truthful. The first reason I gave you is that Friar Lawrence could have told everybody. He agreed to marry Paris and Juliet after Friar had married Romeo and Juliet. This leads to Romeo thinking Juliet is dead and killing himself. The two families might have understood there children’s to marry each other if it was coming from a Friar. Lawrence could have also told Paris to not marry Juliet when Paris was talking to him. “I married them; and there stol’n marriage day” Act V Scene III Line 233. At the end of the story Friar finally admits that he married the two, and he was wrong for doing so. The second reason is that Friar shouldn’t have given Juliet the potion. Giving Juliet the potion have to many things that could have gone wrong. Friar then tries to send a letter to Romeo, it never gets to him because of a plague. Balthasar then gives Romeo the wrong information about Juliet. This ends up having Romeo think Juliet is dead then killing himself, then Juliet seeing Romeo dead killed …show more content…
Friar Lawrence was dishonest and didn’t try and protect young adults that made immature decisions. He let them die. A counter argument for Friar Lawrence shouldn’t have given Juliet the potion is that it was he only choice. It wasn’t Friar could have helped Juliet escape or just tell everybody the truth. Romeo and Juliet were too young to know what they were doing and Friar Lawrence didn’t help them at all. “Let my old life be sacrificed some hour before his time unto the rigor of severest law” Act V Scene III Line 268-69. Friar Lawrence realized what he did was
First, Friar Lawrence agrees to marry Romeo and Juliet to end the feuding between the families. He says, “In one respect I’ll thy assistant be:/ For this alliance may so happy prove/ To turn your households’ rancour to pure love.” (2.3.90-92). Secondly, he organizes a plan for Juliet to take the potion to fake her death. In the plan he also decides to send a message to Romeo explaining their plans but Friar John says “I could not send it – here it is again –/ Nor get a messenger to bring it thee,” (5.2.14-15) to Friar Lawrence so Romeo was never informed of the plan. Lastly, at the end of the play when he finds Juliet and a dead Romeo, he leaves and says “Come go, good Juliet, I dare no longer stay.” (5.3.159). Once both sides are involved, it means Romeo and Juliet must be
Friar Laurence makes not only one, but three mistakes that will eventually lead up to Romeo and Juliet’s death. The Friar’s first mistake was giving Juliet, an unstable fourteen year old, a powerful potion that would make her look dead, so she would not have to marry Paris. Friar Laurence actually shows his irresponsibility by saying, “Thou hast the strength of will to slay thyself…take thou this vial…no warmth, no breath shall testify the livest”( Act 4.1.). Had Friar Laurence not given Juliet the poison, she never would have been put in the position that she was in, which lead to her death.
In conclusion, Friar Lawrence is guilty for the death of Romeo and Juliet is because he gave Juliet the potion, he knew how Romeo would react the way he did, and he had left Juliet by herself when she found out Romeo was dead. He had known what he was giving Juliet and what the outcome might contain. Friar Lawrence had been around romeo many times and knew how he acted. He knew he was dramatic and blew things up way out of proportion. Lastly, He should
Without even thinking about it Friar Lawrence's plan was a terrible plan just out of common sense as there were too many things out of the Friar’s control that could have happened. First, he has to worry if the potion even will work when Juliet takes it or even if she takes it at all. Then he has to worry about getting the word to Romeo about the plan which of course never happened. “But look thou stay not till the watch be set, For then thou canst not pass to Mantua; Where thou shalt live, till we can find a time To blaze your marriage, reconcile your friends, Beg pardon of the prince, and call thee back With twenty hundred thousand times more joy Than thou went'st forth in lamentation.” (4.2.100-105). Here Friar Lawrence explains his badly thought-out plan. His impulsive acts and plans end up getting him in trouble and costing Verona to Young people's lives. His plans failed because he did not take his time and did not think of being more reasonable because his Solutions were completely unrealistic. In a way, Friar Lawrence could be seen as a little bit selfish. Friar Laurence's religion does not permit already married people to get married. This would mean that the Friar would be going against his oaths. Marrying Romeo and Juliet when Juliet already has an arranged marriage with Paris would have
First of all, Friar Lawrence explicitly knew better than to do many of the things he did. First, he should not have agreed to marry Romeo and Juliet so quickly. Romeo wanted to marry Juliet after
He took it upon himself and married Romeo and Juliet without any consent. Friar Lawrence states “Here comes the lady. O, so light a foot will never wear out the everlasting flint. A lover may bestride the gossamers that idles in the wanton summer air, and yet not fall, so light is vanity” (2.6.16-20). Juliet rushes to the cell to marry Romeo. Without questioning Romeo’s love for Juliet any further, he marries the couple. All along he knew they were star crossed lovers but continued with his plan. “Bid her devise some means to come to shrift” (2.4.160) says the Friar. He married the two in secret behind the backs of two feuding families which then added to the tragedy and made things worse. Friar lawrence's idea to secrecy was not a strong plan. Anger built up and secrets were not kept for
As you can see on page 453 the Friar says to Juliet, “This distilled liquor drink thou off; When presently through all thy veins shall run a cold drowsy humor.” What the Friar is describing are the effects of the potion if Juliet drinks it. Another way the Friar is guilty of murder is that he didn't deliver the letter to Romeo himself, if he wouldn't have given the letter to Friar John and just delivered the letter himself then Romeo would have known about Juliet’s ‘Death’. As you can see on page 468, Romeo was expecting a letter from the Friar but doesn't receive one. “Dost thou not bring me letters from the Friar?” Even though Friar Lawrence is mostly the blame for the two teen’s deaths it is also the Capulet’s faults because Mr. And Mrs. Capulet pushed Juliet to marry Paris. Mr. Capulet even disowned his poor daughter because at first she declined her father’s proposal to marry Paris (page 444). But, the deaths of Romeo and
Friar Lawrence is guilty because of his affiliation with the wedding between Romeo and Juliet. When Romeo is banished from Verona, Juliet was being forced to marry Count Paris. Juliet tries to avoid this and asks Friar for advice. Friar tells
Friar Lawrence knew about Romeo and Juliet getting married. He could have stopped them from getting married if he wanted to but he never stopped them. Also he made up a plan to get Juliet out of marrying Paris. He says “Hold then.Go home, be merry, give consent to marry paris.”(4.1.90) because this is his plan to get her away. Friar Lawrence made a potion for Juliet to drink so she can act dead. Lastly he tried sending a letter to Romeo even though he was banished. The letter was to get Romeo to come back and get Juliet even though he was banished. These are the reasons why Friar Lawrence should be
First and for most, I personally believe that Friar Lawrence was the cause of Romeo and Juliet's death. I believe so because if he had not said anything to Friar John which is an untrustworthy individual no one woukd have never knew about the relationship between Romeo and Juliet. He also kept the secrets from the Capulet's he stated " Your part in her you could not keep from death, but heaven keeps his parts in eternal life" (Shakespeare 4,5). This was stating that there was nothing they could have done to save Juliet.
The reason is because, Friar Lawrence married Romeo and Juliet off to soon. Juliet is only thirteen and they have only known each other for one night. Also, Friar did not tell anyone about the marriage. This lead to another marriage with Count Paris and a plan to fake a death. The quote “Wisely and slow they stumble that run fast” (Act 2 Scene 3 line 94).
Friar Lawrence eventually marries the two without their parents knowing. Because he married Romeo and Juliet and gave Juliet a remedy, it causes an even more tragic event in the end; Friar Lawrence is not mainly responsible for what happens in the end. In section C “I’ll thy assistant be” Juliet states: “Tell me not, friar, that thou hear’st of this unless thou tell me how I may prevent it… God join’d my heart and Romeo’s, thou our hands.” The friar responds “And, if thou darest, I’ll give thee remedy.” (Roden Molly)
Although Friar Lawrence is accused in my eyes, Romeo could also potentially be the cause of the issues that happen in the story. Romeo has a noticeable character flaw. He acts
Lastly, another reason that caused Romeo and Juliet’s deaths is Friar Lawrence. I said Friar Lawrence because he didn’t come up with the best ideas. One example of this is when he came up with a long and tricky plan that only worked if everyone knew what was going on. Secondly, he decided to give Juliet the potion which made everyone think she was dead, even Romeo because he wasn’t fully aware of the plan. Lastly, Friar Lawrence didn’t help Romeo and Juliet meet face to face so that he could explain the plan to both parties. Instead, he only shared it with
At this moment, Friar Lawrence should know that marrying Romeo and Juliet wasn’t a good idea. “Be off and comfort her. But mind you don’t stay still the night guards start their shift! Then, you couldn’t leave for Mantua, where you shall live till the time is right for us to make your marriage public… (167)”, Friar tells Romeo. As a priest and an adult, Friar should try to intervene between Romeo and Juliet’s marriage; he knows that Romeo is a menace to society, and that Romeo and Juliet would do everything for their “love”. But, instead of trying to stop Romeo from doing something worse, Friar is supporting him after Romeo killed Tybalt; consequently, Romeo is now able to do worse things. Additionally, Friar helps Juliet to get away from the marriage that her father organized between Paris and her. “Go home, be cheerful, and say you’ll marry Paris… When you’re in bed, take this small bottle and swallow this distilled liquid… When the bridegroom comes in the morning to get you up, there you are-dead. (197)”, Friar tells Juliet. This results in the Capulets thinking that their daughter is dead, even though she isn’t. Because of the help that Friar is providing to Juliet, Romeo now thinks that Juliet is dead; Friar didn’t think about the consequences of the letter not getting in time to Romeo; therefore, Romeo is going back to Verona-where he shouldn’t be, and could get killed because of