preview

Deinstitutionalization In Canada

Decent Essays

The Government of Canada, as well as adjoining non-profit organizations such as the Mental Health Commission of Canada, has released studies examining the number and outcome of interactions between the police and PMI. From these reports, the need to improve and reduce the number of interactions is clear. “It is generally taken as a given that the number of calls involving police contact with PMI has been increasing since the late 1960s and 1970s”, despite the fact that “the empirical bases for the claim [of increasing PIM-police contact] are not well established” (CRCC RCMP, 2010). While there is not an extensive amount of empirical evidence, Statistics Canada’s report on mental health and police contact (Boyce, Rotenberg, & Karam, 2015) …show more content…

Bachrach, the author of dozens of articles on mental health, reports on the development deinstitutionalization in “Deinstitutionalisation: promises, problems and prospects” (1995). Bachrach argues that deinstitutionalization is not a perfect solution to the problem of the treatment of PMI and supports her argument with discussions about both the drawbacks and “positive legacy” of deinstitutionalization. She explains that deinstitutionalization has three parts: the release of patients into the community, the diversion of possible new patients and the development of newer community programs; Bachrach logically explains that the last process is “particularly important” because it impacts the entirety of the patients new independent life in the community. Multiple sources remarked that the third step of deinstitutionalization had not been properly handled (SOURCES?), one author going so far as to call the last step, and deinstitutionalization as a whole, an “abject failure” (Kara, 2014). While the author supports this claim with the consequences that things such as the lack of community resources has had on the population of PMI, she does not concede any of the positive outcomes of deinstitutionalization making her argument somewhat one sided. The article explains that while institutions began closing, “hundreds of vulnerable people were displaced” to communities that were not properly equipped to support them. An article from the Canadian Mental Health Association website by Diana Ballon supports this claim with a more concrete figure stating that since 1950s and 60s and the beginnings of deinstitutionalization there has been “the closure of almost 80 percent of beds in psychiatric hospitals” (n.d.). This increase of PMI living in communities with a lack of proper housing lead to a disproportionally large number of PMI being homeless or living in poverty which “greatly increase[s] the odds of PMI

Get Access