preview

Auditor Audit Case

Decent Essays

1. Identify the control objectives that would be satisfied by the recommendations the internal auditors proposed during the 2014 audit. Explain how each objective would be met by the recommended procedures. One satisfied control objective is the completeness of the transaction. Using a receipt creates a written record of the transaction. Because receipts are pre-numbered, each receipt is paired with a specific check or amount of cash. This allows there to be a reconciliation between the total deposited at the bank, and total recorded on the receipts. Pre-numbering also aids with the existence objective. It prevents someone from throwing the receipt away because you can easily see that there is a missing receipt. A third objective is a segregation …show more content…

The purpose of using segregation of duties is to prevent a person from committing fraud. The tasks performed by Sally, violate the principle of segregation of duties because she was performing the entire cash recording and handling function. Sally collected the copies retained by the physician, by the cashier, and she prepared the daily deposit. There was no oversight to hold her accountable for what she was doing and reporting.
3. (a) Briefly explain the auditor’s responsibility regarding fraud in a non-public company audit. According to AU-C Section 240 paragraph .05, when conducting an audit in accordance with GAAS, an auditor is responsible for obtaining reasonable assurance that the financial statements are free from material misstatement due to error or fraud (2012, December 15). To obtain reasonable assurance, the auditor is responsible for maintaining professional skepticism, considering management’s ability to override controls, and recognizing that audit procedures for detecting error may not be effective in detecting fraud according to paragraph .08 (2012, December …show more content…

An incentive to misappropriate assets can exist when an individual is living beyond their means (2012, December 15). One red flag was Sally’s lifestyle. Shortly after starting at the CHS, her husband suffered a serious back injury at work, leaving him unable to work. A few years later, one of her children was involved in a car accident resulting in large, uninsured medical bills. Sally’s salary was never above $40,000. Despite these factors, her family was able to build a modest home in 2009 based on her salary alone. Sally had an incentive to embezzle since her salary alone could not cover all of these costs. According to AU-C Section 240 paragraph .A7, a misappropriation of assets is often accompanied with misleading financial statements (2012, December 15). A second red flag was when the new director of the CHS believed that money was missing. Based on a fiscal analysis, he knew that the profit margin percentage had not changed, but somehow net profits were decreasing even though revenue and expenses were both increasing due to servicing more students. This unexplainable scenario should have led management to consider the possibility of

Get Access