preview

A Comparison Of The Short Story 'The Monkey's Paw, By Ricky Lewis Jr'

Good Essays

W. W. Jacobs wrote the short story “The Monkey’s Paw” in 1902. A great number of adaptations of the story have since been created using different forms of media. The two which are being compared here are the play adaptation The Monkey’s Paw dramatized by Mara Rockliff and the 2011 film version The Monkey’s Paw by Ricky Lewis Jr. Both the play and film feature the White family receiving a monkey’s paw by which three wishes may be granted. The paw had a spell put on it by a holy man who wanted to show that fate rules people’s lives and that if people try to interfere, they will be sorry. The main differences between the play and the film are that film gives more background information about how and why the paw was obtained, uses more …show more content…

This setting does not convey the same feeling danger or foreshadowing of trouble to come. The viewer may question in the play version why Morris would proceed with making wishes upon the paw after stating that the first owner had wished for death. The information given through the film of Morris seeking out the fakir in order to change his bad fortunes and being the person who requested a spell be placed to grant wishes plants the seed for the viewer that Morris may have already been in a desperate situation and therefore the viewer can more easily accept that he would wish upon it. As the plot in both adaptations develop, Morris’ visit to the White’s home is portrayed differently. The use of alcohol in the film prior to Morris displaying the paw to the family could be interpreted as an action taken only after his wits have been inhibited. The film uses flash backs to dramatize the power of the paw when it is mentioned during the conversation with the White family. The potential harm that can be caused by the paw is better expressed in the Lewis film version by Morris when he is asked why he kept it he stated that, “he kept it to guard it”. He never allows any of the family to handle the paw and it is not until Mr. White takes it away from him as he is attempting to throw it in the fire. At the end of the evening when Morris was leaving he tries to get Mr.

Get Access